Skip to content

Insights

What is a disadvantage of value-based pricing for your agency?

The main disadvantage of value-based pricing is that the fee stops moving when the hours do. Every extra hour comes out of your profit, not the client's budget. You carry the delivery risk, and if you stop logging hours you cannot see what it costs.

Mohammad Azam, Aprecity Consultants · 5 min read

Priced at $160. Delivered at $120 an hour.

Why a fixed price can earn less than hourly

You price the project on what it is worth to the client, not on your hours. The fee is higher, and the client stops auditing your timesheet.

The trade is that your fee is now fixed and your hours are not. When the work grows, the client pays the same and you pay the difference.

What an overrun costs

Effective hourly rate = fixed fee / hours actually worked

Take a branding agency that prices a rebrand at $48,000. It plans 300 hours, and each hour costs $90 to deliver with overhead.

Two extra rounds of revisions take the job to 400 hours.

One branding agency, one rebrand
LineAs plannedAs delivered
Fee$48,000$48,000
Hours300400
Effective hourly rate$160$120
Delivery cost$27,000$36,000
Profit$21,000$12,000
Margin43.8%25.0%

These figures describe a branding agency chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not a client result.

The 100 extra hours cost $9,000, and all of it comes out of profit. Billed hourly, the client would have paid for them.

Why you often do not see it

Many agencies stop logging hours once they stop billing by the hour. The invoice goes out at $48,000 and the project looks like a win.

Without the hours, you cannot tell a $160 project from a $120 one. You quote the next rebrand at the same price and repeat the loss.

Run it on your own numbers

  1. ( 01 )

    Pick your last three fixed-price projects

    Use finished work, so the fee and the hours are both final.

  2. ( 02 )

    Total the hours actually worked

    If nobody logged them, rebuild them from calendars and task lists. Include your own.

  3. ( 03 )

    Divide the fee by the hours

    That is the effective hourly rate each project earned.

  4. ( 04 )

    Compare with the plan

    Set it beside the hours you quoted on. The extra hours times your hourly cost is the profit you gave away.

  5. ( 05 )

    Find where the hours went

    Extra revision rounds, late feedback and added deliverables each need a different fix.

What to do with the answer

Keep value-based pricing, and keep the timesheet. Write the revision rounds and deliverables into the scope, and price anything beyond them as a change order.

Add a margin for risk to each quote, sized by your own overruns. Then the price reflects the value, and your profit survives the delivery.

The service behind this

Fractional CFO

We read your numbers every month and bring you the decision. Profit on each client, a forecast that reaches past the next payroll, and a straight answer on pricing and hiring.

Fractional CFO for marketing agencies

Next step

Found something you cannot explain?

That is the useful outcome. Bring the number to a 20 minute call and we will work out what is behind it.